Nestled in Woodland Park, NJ, Café Colombia is a cozy gem that brings the vibrant flavors of Colombia right to your neighborhood. This humble cafe has earned a devoted following thanks to its authentic Colombian offerings, from freshly brewed coffee to traditional pastries. My visit here was a true delight, revealing why diners like Edwin Moran and Venecia Del Rosario keep returning.

The highlight, without a doubt, is their Colombian cheese buns—buñuelos—light, airy dough balls infused with cheese that burst with flavor in every bite. Served warm, they pair beautifully with the cafe’s rich, aromatic coffee, crafted with care to deliver a genuine Colombian coffee experience. Alongside these, the empanadas stand out, praised for their perfect balance of crispy exterior and savory filling. Jack Alom’s company order of 100 empanadas speaks volumes about their quality and appeal.

What impresses me most about Café Colombia is how a small shop, led by Hugo and his family, maintains consistent quality and heartfelt service. It’s not just about the food; it’s the warm, inviting atmosphere that draws locals like Yesenia back time and again. The bakery items, though sometimes fleeting by afternoon, are a testament to the freshness and craftsmanship behind every treat.

While there are minor points to consider—like the absence of freshly squeezed orange juice mentioned by Edwin and parking challenges—the overall experience is memorable and authentic. For anyone seeking a genuine taste of Colombian culinary culture wrapped in a welcoming environment, Café Colombia offers a flavorful journey worth savoring.